Latest

From Radio to Social Media: What Has Really Changed?

EXPLAINER
A retro radio receiver on a wooden surface, representing the history of broadcasting and public communication.
Photo: Skylar Kang via Pexels · Pexels License

Concerns about media influence did not begin with social platforms. The public reaction to a 1938 radio broadcast reveals how technological change, competing news organisations and assumptions about audiences can shape the stories societies tell about communication.

On 30 October 1938, American radio listeners heard a dramatic account of Martians invading Earth. The broadcast was fiction: Orson Welles's adaptation of H. G. Wells's The War of the Worlds, presented through simulated news bulletins.

The following morning, newspapers reported widespread panic. The episode became a familiar example of supposedly powerful media overwhelming an uncritical audience.

Yet the history is more complicated. And that complication offers a useful way of questioning contemporary claims about social-media misinformation.

THE MEDIA-PANIC COMPARISON

Three distinctions that prevent historical analogy from becoming oversimplification.

1938 · RADIO

Some listeners were frightened. Newspapers reported a much larger public crisis.

TODAY · PLATFORMS

False information may spread widely, but reach alone does not establish belief.

SHARED QUESTION

Who defines the public problem, which evidence supports it and who benefits from that interpretation?

AUDIENCE RESPONSE · DISTRIBUTION · INDUSTRY COMPETITION · PUBLIC AUTHORITY

A comparison of research questions.

What the historical record actually shows

The Rockefeller Archive Center's examination of the broadcast documents frightened listeners, alarming newspaper coverage and research efforts that followed the programme.

Some people mistook the fictional bulletins for actual news, particularly when they missed contextual information. But isolated reactions do not establish that an entire national audience believed the story.

That distinction matters because the event's lasting reputation was shaped not only by radio listening, but by how the incident was described afterwards.

The institutions telling the story

Radio and newspapers were competing sources of news and public attention. Newspaper warnings about radio's influence therefore emerged within an industry undergoing its own changes.

In an archival study, Pooley and Socolow (2013) revisited the research behind the broadcast's reputation. They challenged familiar accounts of the investigation, including the way its findings and authorship were remembered.

This doesn't mean nobody was frightened. Instead, it suggests that the evidence about public reactions should be considered separately from the later narrative of nationwide panic.

The contemporary parallel

Today, concerns about false information often focus on how rapidly claims spread through digital platforms. There is substantial evidence that circulation patterns can differ between true and false content.

In their 2018 study of approximately 126,000 verified story cascades, Vosoughi, Roy and Aral found that false stories travelled more widely and rapidly than true stories on X/Twitter.

But circulation is not identical to belief. People can share claims to endorse, question, criticise or mock them. A measure of reach cannot, by itself, reveal the private meaning of every interaction.

War of the Worlds Preview · PBS American Experience

Comparison limits

Radio broadcasting was organised around a relatively limited number of stations and scheduled transmissions. Social platforms allow many people to publish, respond and recirculate material through personalised interfaces.

Van Dijck and Poell (2013) describe how programmability, popularity, connectivity and datafication help organise social-media communication. These arrangements introduce forms of selection and measurement that cannot simply be equated with 1930s radio.

The common concern is media influence. The institutional conditions, available evidence and ways people participate are different.

History leaves us questioning

Looking back at the 1938 broadcast reveals something interesting: a media event and the public story told about it are not necessarily the same thing. Some listeners were genuinely frightened, while subsequent accounts gave the incident a much broader meaning.

Similar questions arise today. Contemporary communication technologies introduce new possibilities and risks, but the way societies interpret them also reflects existing relationships, expectations and institutional interests. Recognising historical parallels need not diminish what is genuinely different.

Perhaps one of the more interesting questions is how an event moves from something people encounter through the media to a story they discuss, interpret and eventually come to understand together.

Key sources

Miller, L. (2021). War of the Worlds: Rockefeller philanthropies, disinformation, and media literacy in the 1930s. Rockefeller Archive Center.

Pooley, J., & Socolow, M. J. (2013). Checking up on The Invasion from Mars: Hadley Cantril, Paul F. Lazarsfeld, and the making of a misremembered classic. International Journal of Communication, 7, 1920–1948.

Vosoughi, S., Roy, D., & Aral, S. (2018). The spread of true and false news online. Science, 359(6380), 1146–1151.

van Dijck, J., & Poell, T. (2013). Understanding social media logic. Media and Communication, 1(1), 2–14.

Comments

Popular

Character Assassination, Repetition and the Erosion of Trust: The Anatomy of a Smear

The Architecture of Spectacle: A Multidisciplinary Analysis of the Psychology, Sociology, and Ontological Impact of Reality Television

Beyond Fact-Checking: Prebunking and the Future of Digital Information Integrity